CA. Akhilesh Kumarcaakhilesh.in
PERSONAL FINANCESame Gold, FourBills: Where theMoney Really GoesLow making proves nothing about purity. Themoney moves to the rate, wastage and stones.Compare the final bill per gram of pure gold.CA Akhilesh Kumar· caakhilesh.inSAME GOLD, FOUR BILLSPAID ABOVE IBJA VALUE · 10 G OF 22 CARAT · ₹12% MAKING22,9833% + WASTAGE19,885FREE MAKING20,173GENUINE 4%12,114RATE GAPMAKINGWASTAGEGSTTHE MAKING CHARGE IS ONLY ONE LINE ON THE BILLMY EXAMPLES · RATES OF 6 NOV 2026 · NOT REAL BILLS₹232–28222K rate aboveIBJA, per gram2 timesCompensationif purityfalls short12.7%Gross marginat one listedjewellerSAME GOLD, FOUR BILLSPAID ABOVE IBJA VALUE · 10 G OF 22 CARAT · ₹12% MAKING22,9833% + WASTAGE19,885FREE MAKING20,173GENUINE 4%12,114RATE GAPMAKINGWASTAGEGSTTHE MAKING CHARGE IS ONLY ONE LINE ON THE BILLMY EXAMPLES · RATES OF 6 NOV 2026 · NOT REAL BILLSNº 50
Personal Finance · Updated · 12 min read · Summary infographic ↓

The Making Charge Game in Gold and Silver: What Is Behind the 3%, 2.5% and Free Making Reels?

Every two or three swipes on Instagram, a jeweller offers gold jewellery at 3% making, 2.5%, or even free. Is the gold pure, or is the customer being fooled? I read the BIS rules, the listed jewellers' accounts and the day's published gold rates to find where the money really moves, and how you can check any bill yourself.

By CA Akhilesh Kumar ACA, Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (2022) · Gurgaon
Personal FinanceGold

Nowadays opening Instagram is difficult. Every two or three swipes, a reel shows a jeweller offering gold jewellery at a making charge of 3%. Another says 2.5%. Some say free making. What is the game behind this? Is the gold really pure, or are they fooling customers with low quality and less purity? I went to the rulebook of the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS), the accounts of listed jewellers and the gold rates published on the same day to find out.

Written on 6 November 2026. Gold and silver rates are IBJA's morning rates of 6 November, before GST; its evening rate was not out at 4:40 pm. Jewellers' rates were read on their own websites the same day. The example bills are my own, not any jeweller's real bill. I have not tested jewellery from any reel, and I am not saying any particular seller is cheating. This is not investment advice.

The answer in six lines

Is the gold 100% pure? No jewellery is; 22 carat is 91.6% gold · Does low making mean low purity? Not by itself, and I found no official data linking the two · Is 3% possible? Yes, on plain pieces and coins · The game: the money can move to the gold rate, wastage, stones and buyback · Your test: final bill divided by grams of pure gold · Your protection: the HUID, a proper bill, and double compensation if purity falls short

First, is the gold 100% pure?

Let me clear the biggest doubt first. No jewellery is 100% pure, and an honest jeweller will never say so. Pure gold is too soft to wear every day, so it is mixed with other metals. What you are owed is the purity written on the piece, and a hallmark that backs it.

Mark on the pieceGold in itPure gold in 10 gramsIBJA rate, 1 gram
24K99999.9%9.99 grams₹14,102
22K91691.6%9.16 grams₹12,918
18K75075%7.5 grams₹10,577
14K58558.5%5.85 grams₹8,250

The making charge has nothing to do with this table. A jeweller can charge 3% on honest 22 carat, or 20% on a piece that is short. So a low making charge is not proof of bad gold, and a high one is not proof of good gold. Only the hallmark, and in a dispute a test, can tell you.

Your fear is still the right one to start with, because of the size of the loss. If 18 carat is sold to you at the 22 carat price, you lose ₹2,341 a gram on IBJA's rates, or ₹23,410 on 10 grams. No making charge discount can give you that back.

Can a jeweller really live on 3%?

Sometimes, yes. A paid press release for Tanishq, carried by ANI in April, says its making charges start from 7%, with gold coins as low as 3%. The same release explains why charges vary: a machine-made piece takes far less labour than a handmade one. A plain chain or a coin does not need a karigar for 40 days. So 3% on a simple piece is not a fairy tale.

But look at what a whole jewellery business has to earn to stay open. Listed companies must publish this, so these are not guesses.

Listed jewellerPeriodWhat it reported
P N Gadgil JewellersJuly to September 2026Gross margin 12.7%, profit after tax 4.5%
Titan (Tanishq, Mia, Zoya)July to September 2026Operating margin 11.1%, leaving out a one-time customs duty benefit (14.3% with it)
Kalyan JewellersApril to June 2026Profit before tax about 5.1%, leaving out bullion, as its management told analysts

These are whole-company numbers. They include diamonds, so they are not the making charge itself. But they show the scale. P N Gadgil needed a gap of nearly 13% between what its goods cost and what it sold them for, and after rent, staff, interest and tax it kept about 4.5 paise of every rupee. It also calls coin sales low-margin and is moving away from them.

A small shop with no mall rent can survive on far less, and I do not want to call every low price a trick. But a showroom cannot sell everything at 3% and pay its bills. So whenever you see 3%, ask two things: on which piece, and where does the rest come from?

So what is the game? Seven places the money can move

An investment banker's post reported by Business Today called 0% making a marketing trick and listed several hidden costs. That is one person's view, so I checked each idea against rules and published numbers. Here is what stood up.

1. The gold rate on the board. This is the biggest one, and few people look at it. Every jeweller sets its own rate, and it is not the rate you see in the news.

22 carat, 1 gram, 6 November 2026RateAbove IBJA
IBJA morning rate (916)₹12,918—
Malabar, updated 3:35 pm₹13,150₹232 (1.8%)
Tanishq₹13,190₹272 (2.1%)
CaratLane₹13,200₹282 (2.2%)

There is nothing wrong in this. IBJA's rate is a benchmark, and a shop's rate carries its own costs. Tanishq's published rate stayed 1.6% to 2.1% above IBJA's morning rate on each of the last five trading days. Kalyan told analysts in August that it earns a small markup of 0.5% to 0.75% between its store rate and the spot rate at which it buys bullion. But see what this means. A 2% gap in the rate is almost as large as the whole "3% making" in the reel. At these prices, every ₹100 a gram on the board adds ₹1,000 on 10 grams. A seller whose rate is ₹400 above the big chains has quietly taken back all of the 3%. So the first question for any reel is: what is your 22 carat rate per gram today, before GST?

2. Wastage or VA. In many shops a second line appears: wastage, or value addition (VA). "3% making" plus 8% wastage is 11%. I found no BIS rule that fixes a making or wastage charge, so the seller is free to use both names. Add them together before you compare.

3. Only some designs. The reel shows a heavy necklace, but the 3% applies to plain chains. Big chains do the same in a cleaner way: Malabar's site shows "up to 30%" off making charges, and "up to" is the part to read. Ask for the charge on this exact piece.

4. Stones, wax and lac weighed as gold. You should pay the gold rate only on gold. The rule is clear: the bill of a hallmarked article must show the net weight of precious metal separately. Malabar says its tags show gross weight, stone weight and net gold weight, and every shop can do the same. If 0.5 gram of stones in a 10 gram piece is billed as gold, you pay about ₹6,595 extra. Hollow and filled pieces exist too: BIS tells its testing centres to record in the report if they suspect a piece is hollow, wax filled or of mixed metals.

5. The piece is not what it says. This is your direct doubt, so let me be honest. It does happen. In January 2023, BIS raided six places in Maharashtra, and two establishments in Mumbai's Zaveri Bazar were found doing fake hallmarking, with about 2.75 kg of jewellery seized. In June 2026, BIS seized jewellery in Hyderabad that was being sold without the mandatory hallmark or with old markings. But I found no official data showing that low-making sellers are the ones doing this. So I will not claim it. You do not need to guess either, because you can check, as shown below.

6. The exit. A low price going in can be taken back when you sell. Malabar advertises 100% value on gold exchange, which is a promise for exchange, at its own store. Kalyan told analysts that when it buys old gold for cash, it buys at a discount to the spot price. The banker in Business Today says buyback can fall to 70% to 80% on zero-making pieces, which is his claim, not a published rule. Before you buy, ask for the deduction on exchange and on cash, in writing.

7. Cash, no bill. "No GST if you pay cash" sounds like a 3% saving. It is the worst deal of all, because the bill is your only proof. Under the Consumer Protection Act, not issuing a bill or cash memo is itself an unfair trade practice. Without the bill you have no net weight, no purity and no case. A seller also cannot take ₹2 lakh or more in cash from you for one purchase.

The one number that beats every reel

Forget the making percentage. Take the final bill with GST, and divide it by the grams of pure gold in the piece, which is net weight multiplied by purity. Now every offer speaks the same language. The gold making charge calculator does this for up to three quotes, for gold or silver. Here are five bills, each for 10 grams, all with 3% GST on the whole amount.

BillWhat the tag saysRate, 1 gramFinal billPer gram of pure goldAbove IBJA 24K
AShowroom, 12% making₹13,190₹1,52,160₹16,61117.8%
B"3% making", plus 5% wastage₹13,400₹1,49,062₹16,27315.4%
C"Free making"₹14,500₹1,49,350₹16,30515.6%
DGenuine 4% making₹13,190₹1,41,291₹15,4259.4%
E"3% making", but really 18 carat₹13,190₹1,39,933₹18,65832.3%

My own examples, not real bills. A to D are 22 carat. Hallmarking fee left out. IBJA's 24 carat rate was ₹14,102 a gram.

Read it slowly. Bills B and C shout 3% and free against 12%, yet they save only about ₹3,000. Bill D is a true saving of ₹10,869, and that seller deserves your business if the piece is honest. Bill E has the lowest total and is by far the worst, because you got 7.5 grams of gold instead of 9.16. That is the whole game in one table: the headline number is the one that matters least.

One fair warning. Compare like with like. A machine-made chain and a handmade necklace should not cost the same to make, so a higher charge on real craftsmanship is not a cheat.

How to check the purity yourself

  1. Find the three marks. The BIS logo, the purity such as 22K916, and a six-character HUID. BIS says each piece of a pair, and each detachable part, should carry the hallmark.
  2. Use the shop's magnifying glass. BIS requires the shop to keep one of at least 10 times magnification, to display its registration certificate, and to show the carat and fineness chart.
  3. Verify the HUID. Enter the code under "Verify HUID" in the BIS CARE app before you pay. BIS says this confirms the purity and gives the jeweller's registration number. If it fails, or the details do not match the piece and the bill, stop there.
  4. Read the bill. It must separately show each article, the net weight of precious metal, the purity in carat and fineness, and the hallmarking charge. The fee jewellers pay the centre rose to ₹75 a gold piece, plus tax, on 14 September 2026. It is per piece, not by weight, and it does not include making or wastage.
  5. In doubt, get it tested. Any BIS-recognised hallmarking centre will test a consumer's piece. BIS's guidelines of 2022 set ₹45 an article, with a ₹200 minimum, so confirm the fee first. Know the two methods: XRF does no damage but reads only the surface, while fire assay is the accurate one, and it needs a small sample cut from the piece.

If a hallmarked piece does test lower than marked, the law is on your side. The jeweller who sold it must pay you two times the value of the shortage, plus the testing charges. Suppose a 10 gram piece marked 916 tests at 875. That is 0.41 gram of gold short, about ₹5,782 at IBJA's 24 carat rate, so roughly ₹11,564 plus the test fee. The rule as I read it does not say which day's rate applies, so treat this as a rough guide.

Where the hallmark does not reach

This part is rarely said in the reels. Mandatory hallmarking has real gaps, so "the law requires it" does not cover every piece.

Not coveredWhat the order saysWhat you do
Pieces under 2 gramsExemptSmall nose pins and earrings need not be hallmarked. Get the purity on the bill
Kundan, polki and jadauExempt as special categoriesBuy where you can go back, and get net gold weight and purity in writing
Gold coins and barsTreated as bullion, outside this orderCheck the maker and the stated purity on the pack and the bill
Jewellers with turnover up to ₹40 lakh a yearExemptA very small seller may legally sell without a hallmark. Ask for one anyway
Districts not on the listThe order covers 392 notified districtsOnline sellers can be anywhere. Ask for the HUID before you pay

The same game in silver

In silver I would be even more careful, because the hallmark is not compulsory. The government's update of 4 December 2025 says silver hallmarking is voluntary, but a silver piece that is hallmarked must carry a HUID. BIS's chief said in June 2026 that a mandate would come gradually, and a trade report of 1 September expected it from October. BIS's order page, as I read it on 6 November, still lists only the gold order. So treat it as voluntary until an order appears.

Here the real game is the grade. IBJA's silver rate is for 999 silver: ₹181.86 a gram on 6 November. But the same government update says the 925 and 800 grades make up nearly 90% of hallmarked silver, and 90% of anklets are 800.

Silver gradeSilver in itValue of that silver, 1 gram
99999.9%₹181.86
92592.5%₹168.39
80080%₹145.63

Sell a payal of 800 grade at the 999 rate with "free making", and the seller has earned about 20% with no making charge at all. Per-gram making also looks small in silver. ₹20 a gram sounds like nothing, but on a metal at ₹182 it is 11%. So ask for the grade first, and work out the final bill per gram of pure silver, just as with gold.

A reel is an advertisement, and the same law applies as on television. Under the Consumer Protection Act, the Central Consumer Protection Authority can stop a misleading advertisement, and can fine the manufacturer or endorser up to ₹10 lakh, and up to ₹50 lakh for repeat cases.

The 2022 guidelines on advertising are quite direct on our subject:

  • Free claims. An advertisement cannot call something free if the price you must pay to get it has been raised because of the promotion, or if the quality or quantity has been reduced.
  • Bait advertising. A low-price advertisement must have a reasonable prospect of selling at that price, and it cannot hide restrictions.
  • Disclaimers. A disclaimer cannot be used to hide material information.

So "free making" with a raised gold rate sits badly with these rules. Whether a particular reel breaks them is for the Authority to decide, not for me. For your own safety, do not pay an advance by UPI to a seller found on a reel until you have the shop's address, its BIS registration number, the day's rate in writing and a clear idea of the final bill.

Eight questions before you pay

RateWhat is your rate today?

Per gram, for this purity, before GST. Compare it with IBJA and two chains.

MakingWhat is the charge on this piece?

Not the charge in the reel. This exact design.

WastageIs there wastage or VA?

Add it to the making charge, and look for any other line.

WeightWhat is the net gold weight?

Gross weight, stone weight and net weight, with stones priced separately.

PurityCan I verify the HUID now?

Check it in BIS CARE in the shop, before you pay.

TotalWhat is the final bill?

Ask for the full amount with GST, then divide by pure gold in grams.

ExitWhat do I get back later?

Deductions on exchange and on cash sale, in writing.

BillWill you give a full GST bill?

If the answer is no, the answer to the whole deal is no.

If something goes wrong

  1. Keep everything. The bill, payment proof, the tag and a screenshot of the reel, because reels disappear.
  2. Get the piece tested at a BIS-recognised centre and keep the report.
  3. Ask the jeweller for compensation in writing, quoting the report.
  4. Complain to BIS through the BIS CARE app, its online portal, or complaints@bis.gov.in.
  5. Go to the consumer route. Call the National Consumer Helpline on 1915, and then the District Consumer Commission if needed.

So what is the game? The making charge is one line on a bill of many lines, and the game is to make you look at that line alone. A low charge can be honest. It can also be paid back to the seller through the rate, wastage, stones or buyback, and if the purity is short, no discount can cover the loss. Do the one division, verify the HUID, take the bill, and the reel loses its power over you. If you buy from a big chain, there are also clean ways to cut the bill, such as paying with discounted gift cards.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a 3% making charge on gold genuine? It can be, on plain or machine-made pieces and coins. A paid press release for Tanishq says its coins start at 3%. Check the charge on the exact piece, and compare the final bill per gram of pure gold.

Does zero making charge mean the gold is low purity? Not by itself. I found no official data linking low making charges to low purity. But a free making offer usually means the money is being collected elsewhere, so check the gold rate, net weight and the HUID.

Is 22 carat gold 100% pure? No. 22 carat is 91.6% gold, marked 22K916. Even 24 carat is marked 999, or 99.9%. Jewellery is usually 22 carat or lower.

What is the difference between making charge and wastage? Making charge is what you pay for the work. Wastage, or VA, is a second charge that many shops add for gold said to be lost in making. For your bill, simply add the two together.

Is GST charged on making charges? Yes. On a jewellery bill, 3% GST is charged on the whole amount, the gold and the making charge together.

How do I check a HUID? Open the BIS CARE app, choose "Verify HUID" and enter the six-character code on the piece. Do it before you pay.

What if hallmarked gold tests lower than marked? The jeweller who sold it must pay you two times the value of the shortage, plus the testing charges. Get the test from a BIS-recognised centre and keep the bill.

Is a hallmark compulsory on gold under 2 grams? No. Pieces under 2 grams are exempt, and so are kundan, polki and jadau, and jewellers with turnover up to ₹40 lakh a year. Gold coins and bars are outside the jewellery order too.

Is silver hallmarking compulsory? No, as of 6 November 2026. It is voluntary, but a silver piece that is hallmarked must carry a HUID. Press reports say a mandate may come, so check BIS's site before you rely on this.

Summary

This piece, as an infographic

Download
PERSONAL FINANCEThe Making Charge Game in Gold and Silver:What Is Behind the 3%, 2.5% and Free MakingReels?Low making proves nothing about purity. The money moves to the rate, wastage and stones. Comparethe final bill per gram of pure gold.A REEL OFFERS 3% OR FREE MAKING. WHAT NOW?Does the seller refuse a full bill?Walk away. No bill, noprotectionNext question ↓YESNOIs the HUID valid and the final bill fair?A good deal, whateverthe making saysThe low making is only aheadlineYESNOKEY FIGURES₹232–28222K rate above IBJA, per gram2 timesCompensation if purity falls short12.7%Gross margin at one listedjewellerBEFORE YOU PAY01Ask the ratePer gram, this purity, before GST02Add every chargeMaking, wastage or VA, and stones03Check net weightYou pay the gold rate only on gold04Verify the HUIDIn the BIS CARE app, in the shop05Do one divisionFinal bill by grams of pure goldSAME GOLD, FOUR BILLSPaid above IBJA value on 10 g, ₹ thousand22.9812% making19.893% + wastage20.17Free making12.11Genuine 4%Pure gold in 10 g of jewellery, grams9.9924K9.1622K7.518K5.8514KCOMPARISON SNAPSHOTVSWhat the rules give youHallmark in 392 districtsNet weight shown on the billTesting at BIS centres2 times the shortage if shortWhere they stopPieces under 2 gramsKundan, polki and jadauCoins and barsSilver: hallmark is voluntaryIBJA morning rates and jewellers' published rates of 6 November 2026. Bills are my own examples for 10 gramsof 22 carat, with 3% GST, not real bills. Not investment advice.CA Akhilesh Kumarcaakhilesh.in

Every figure on it comes from the piece above. Share it freely — a link back is all that is asked.

Sources

31 official sources, linked
Bureau of Indian Standards · Department of Consumer Affairs · Gazette of India · Central Consumer Protection Authority, as reproduced by TaxGuru and 16 more

The rules and figures in this article can be checked against these sources.

Use it

The tools for this piece.

Run the figures the piece talks about — everything works in your browser, nothing is stored.